Eva Mendes wore this yellow Dolce & Gabbana silk gown with a large bow, to the launch of the Campari 2008 Calendar in Italy back in November.

She accessorized her gown with a black clutch, which does not work for me.

Actress Bonnie Somerville wore the same dress to the The Art of Elysium 10th Anniversary Gala this weekend.

Although I hate Eva’s clutch, I much prefer the dress against her skin tone, so she wins this for me.

Source & Source

Jennifer Morrison first wore this Marchesa 2008 Resort monochrome strapless embroidered dress to the Us Weekly’s Hot Hollywood event back in September last year.

She wore her dress with a pair of peep-toe shoes and carried a black clutch.

Brittany Snow wore the same dress with an ankle strap pair of peep-toe shoes last night to The Art of Elysium 10th Anniversary Gala.

Despite the fact that these two are identical from the hair to the peep-toes, I will give this one to Jennifer Morrison.

Source

OK, before you all start telling me this is not the same dress, it is.

They are both Dolce & Gabbana 2008 Resort dresses, but just different materials – obviously.

Melissa George wore the leopard print version dress to the 30 Days of Nights premiere back in October with gold peep-toes. She swept her hair to the side and only accessorized with a ring.

Kelly Rowland wore the pink version of this dress to the Dolce & Gabbana Christmas Party in London back in December, with a pair of pink satin pumps.

Melissa wins this easily, as Kelly looks like a big ‘ol bottle of Pepto Bismol.

Source & Source

Cashmere Mafia actress Lucy Liu arrived at the Ed Sullivan Theater in New York for an appearance on Late Show with David Letterman wearing a hot pink Alexander McQueen Spring 2008 dress yesterday.

Her choice is very chic, from the gloves to the asymmetrical seaming to the banded hem.

LOVE, Love, love.

Sienna Miller wore the same dress in black – more somberly – with a pair of platform shoes, to her premiere of Interview in London back in October.

I will easily give this to Lucy Liu, as she went all out to make this dress as edgy as it appeared on the runway. Sienna may have won this, had she at least worn the pink accent. I much prefer Sienna shoes.

Source & Source & Source

Chloe Sevigny first wore this lavender Narciso Rodriguez Spring 2008 dress to the The Diving Bell and the Butterfly premiere in New York back in November. This dress very much suits her sense of style.

Amanda Bynes surprised me by wearing the same dress to the Critic’s Choice Awards last night.

Both carried a black clutches and black shoes. Chloe opted for sandals, whereas Amanda opted for pumps.

This is really hard choice as they both look amazing. For stepping out of her comfort-zone and because it hangs better on her, I think Amanda wore it better, although I prefer Chloe’s choice of shoe.

Source & Source

Mary Kate Olsen first wore her own designs in this Elizabeth & James sequined dress to Zac Posen’s Spring 2007 Fashion Week After Party, sporing a cute pocahontas hairstyle.

Carrie Underwood also wore the same sequined dress on her way to her performance in Times Square on New Years Eve. She teamed her dress with a scarf to keep her warm from the New York chill, a pair of tights, gloves and a pair of black Christian Louboutin Rolando’s.

This dress is available to purchase from Bergdorf Goodman for only $347, reduced from $495.

Mary-Kate wins this for me. Carrie could have come close, if I had seen her in the dress without all the keep warm essentials.

Source & Source

For the 7th on Sale Gala, Anna Wintour arrived wearing a Fall 2007 Chanel Couture ensemble, but by the end of the evening Ashley Olsen was also wearing the same jacket over her Calvin Klein white dress.

Did Ashley dare wear the same jacket to the same event at Ms. Wintour?

No, Ashley bid and won the fabulous jacket in one of the auctions on the night.

Anna did look great, but I think Ashley gives it more life.

Bee Shaffer, Anna’s daughter was also there and she wore a strapless brocade Dolce & Gabbana Spring 2008 dress.

Source & Source