As many of you correctly pointed out Carrie Underwood was the first to wear this gorgeous black sequined Pamella Roland Spring 2009 mini dress with silver sequined circles and bell sleeves when she attended the Clive Davis Pre-Grammy Party.

Silver accessories including earrings, a silver clutch and strappy sandals complemented her dress.

Whitney Port wore the same dress recently to the “I Love Gen Art” 15th Anniversary Benefit in New York.

Whitney wore less bling, just a simple ruby ring.

As much as I dislike Carrie’s hair, I hate Whitney’s choice of pumps with this dress so Carrie wins for me.

Credit: Wireimage & NYmag

French actress Roxane Mesquida was one of the many guests invited to the grand opening of a Roberto Cavalli’s Paris boutique during Paris Fashion Week back in March.

She wore part French maid, part Chinese porcelain black and white strapless printed Roberto Cavalli Spring 2009 bustier dress with black pumps.

Actress Taraji P. Henson wore the same dress to the 2009 MTV Movie Awards in California, with black slingbacks.

Taraji wins this for me as I prefer her slingbacks to Roxane’s heavier pumps, plus Taraji dress is shorter in both the bodice and skirt making it more playful.

Credit: Style.com & Wireimage

Whilst promoting “The Wrestler” last year Marisa Tomei wore this vivid electric blue Alexander McQueen satin shift dress, which she accessorized with a black McQueen skull clasp box clutch and black  pumps.

Fergie showed off her enviable legs in a slightly shorten version of the same dress when she walked the red carpet for the “2009 American Idol Grand Finale”.

Silver strappy heels and a stack of silver bangles were paired with her dress.

TV presenter Terri Seymour wore the same dress last week when she attended the London premiere of “Public Enemies”  in London, which she wore with black peep-toes.

As much as I love Marisa, her dress is the most creased plus it looks one-size too big for her.

Fergie wins for me as I love her silver accessories, plus she modified the dress to show off her best asset - her legs.

This dress is still available on sale from Net-A-Porter International for £616/€735.

Credit: Wireimage

Garcelle Beauvais arrived at US Weekly Hot Hollywood Style Issue Event back in April wearing a head-turning BCBG Max Azria asymmetrical dress with a blouson bodice and a front panel that created a fluid drape.

What really makes this look special is the stunning statement piece that adorns her neck.

Arielle Kebbel kept her dress simple at the “Maxim’s 10th Annual Hot 100 Celebration” in Santa Monica, by just wearing a black pumps and a black clutch.

At the Cannes Film Festival Elsa Pataky attended the “Akvinta Presents A Night of Hollywood Domino Party” wearing the same dress with a less impressive necklace plus a black clutch and bronze peep-toes.

Garcelle wins this by a landslide all thanks to that stunning necklace.

Credit: Style.com & Wireimage

I really loved this Chloé cropped jacket when it was presented within the Pre-Fall 2009 collection, but being the fashion snob that I’m, I can’t help but be disappointed that these two brand killers have worn it.

Lindsay Lohan was first spotted wearing this jacket when leaving a production studio in LA last month.

She wore her jacket with a loose fitting white top, black bell bottom pants, a black waist belt and a blue Chloé Paraty python tote.

After swiftly exiting the “I’m a Celebrity Get Me Out Of Here” jungle Heidi Montag and her husband were in New York to appear on the “Late Night with Jimmy Fallon” show.

She was also wearing the same Chloé cropped jacket with worn jeans, a black silk top, Gucci Rampling platform slingbacks, and an oversized Balenciaga crocodile tote.

Neither are rockin’ my world, but if I had to choose it would be Heidi simply because Lindsay looks a complete and utter mess.

How does Lindsay manage to make expensive pieces always look so cheap?

This Chloé Pre-Fall 2009 cropped jacket is available to purchase from Net-A-Porter’s International site for £1,345 or Browns Fashion for £1,345/€1,567.96/$2,194.37.

Credit: Fame Pictures & Style.com

Claire Danes arrived at the Film Independent’s Spirit Awards held at Santa Monica Beach earlier this year wearing a two tone Lanvin Spring 2009 strapless bustier dress, with a gathered skirt.

Her look was made more interesting with a nude Lanvin necklace from the same collection, but dialed down with uninteresting black peep-toes.

Dasha Zhukova opted for the same Lanvin dress when she attended “The Hermitage 20/21 Dinner at Sotheby’s” in London back in April.

She added a simple gold necklace, taupe heels and a box clutch.

Funny woman Chelsea Handler for once wowed me at the “Women In Film’s 2009 Crystal + Lucy Awards” in California when she walked the red carpet wearing the same dress.

This has to be the most sophisticated I have ever seen Chelsea look, as she paired her dress with champagne heels and a Nancy Gonzalez clutch.

Claire is ruled out because of her uninspiring heels.

Dasha wins because she could make a black bin liner look chic, plus her accessories complemented her look better than the other two.

Credit: Wireimage

Ditching tennis whites in favour of a far more glamorous look, Serena Williams attended the “Ralph Lauren/Sony Ericsson pre-Wimbledon Party” hosted by Richard Branson last week.

The star wore dazzling gold sequined harem trousers with a white tank from Ralph Lauren’s Spring 2009 collection, teamed with gold peep-toes and complementary gold jewelery.

Fashion presenter and journalist Louise Roe arrived at the “Leap Anywhere” Launch Party in London last week wearing the same Ralph Lauren harem pants with a black silk top, black gladiators and a leather jacket.

I much preferred the way Louise wore the pants lower on her hips - as they were intended - so she wins for me.

Credit: Simon Burchell/London Features & Style.com