Who Wore Alexander McQueen Better? Sienna Miller, Lucy Liu, Katie Holmes, Amber Heard, Tinsley Mortimer, Leelee Sobieski or Katie Beckinsale

This WWIB post spans five years and seven celebs proving that an Alexander McQueen piece is truly timeless.

Sienna Miller was the first to wear this Alexander McQueen Spring 2008 draped dress back in October 2007 at the premiere of her film ‘Interview,’ during the BFI 51st London Film Festival.

As Sienna is known for her signature grungy look, I like how simple she keeps it here, with just a loose up-do and black pumps.

Simple was certainly not on Lucy Liu’s mind, however, as she wore the same dress in hot pink to a January 2008 taping of ‘The Late Show with David Letterman’ in New York City. The hot pink plus leather gloves and pointy toes shoes is just too much.

Just a month later, Katie Holmes wore the same dress in houndstooth at the First Annual Essence Black Women In Hollywood Luncheon in LA. Sporting a shag bob the actress paired her dress with eggplant peep-toes and an Alexander McQueen skull clutch.

Resident bombshell Amber Heard tried out the hot pink number at the ‘Never Back Down’ Hollywood premiere in March 2008. Her shoes let her down.

Socialite Tinsley Mortimer posed backstage at a February 2009 Max Azria fashion show, pairing her dress with black accessories, including a Chanel purse.

Actress Leelee Sobieski took the dress in a more unique route at the May 2011 MoMA & MoMA PS1 Celebratory dinner, by pairing the dress with a unique pair of black-and-white woven ankle boots.

Kate Beckinsale supported Eva Longoria’s foundation party in LA last month accessorizing with simple black peep-toes and a high pony.

Who do you think wore it best?

It’s a tough call with so many beautiful ladies and options to choose from, but I think I’d go with Katie Holmes, because I love the print and 2008 was such a chic year for her.

Credit: Getty

Cheryl Cole In Stella McCartney - The X Factor Newcastle Auditions

Cheryl Cole In Stella McCartney – The X Factor Newcastle Auditions

Who Wore Ted Baker Better? Carmen Electra or Emmy Rossum

Who Wore Ted Baker Better? Carmen Electra or Emmy Rossum

19 Responses to Who Wore Alexander McQueen Better? Sienna Miller, Lucy Liu, Katie Holmes, Amber Heard, Tinsley Mortimer, Leelee Sobieski or Katie Beckinsale

  1. la mala March 21, 2012 at 10:23 #

    sienna or katie.

  2. Martin March 21, 2012 at 10:44 #

    Katie Holmes is the winner. It looks amazing!! Look: perfect, smile: amazing!!

  3. dee March 21, 2012 at 13:51 #

    Kate Beckinsale.

  4. Jessica March 21, 2012 at 14:00 #

    On desperate housewives 2 weeks ago, eva longoria’s character wore this or something similar (however I am not 100% sure if it was McQueen) … but in yellow. I would have definitely chose her. But my vote went to Kate Beckinsale here!

  5. Alina March 21, 2012 at 14:25 #

    Kate Beckinsale for me.

  6. Elena March 21, 2012 at 14:41 #

    This kills me to say, because I so wish it where Amber Heard, but it is definitely Katie. The pattern, the pop of color with the shoes. Perfect.

  7. DivaDebbi (Beauty and Fashion Blog) March 21, 2012 at 14:54 #

    Kate is the only one who looks head to toe flawless. She completely sells this look. Amber is my runner up.

  8. lee March 21, 2012 at 15:25 #

    sigh this makes me miss that katie holmes so much

  9. Crack March 21, 2012 at 16:09 #

    What you eat in breakfast FC…to have such amazing memory :)
    Mrs. Holmes for me too..

    • Fashion Critic March 21, 2012 at 16:59 #

      lol :D Frosties

  10. jane March 21, 2012 at 17:23 #

    Surprisingly, Katie Holmes wore it best for me. I like the print and the dizzying effect it has coupled with the tailoring. I also like the purple peep-toes as complimentary color and design accent to her dress.

  11. molly March 21, 2012 at 17:54 #

    This has to be some sort of record for most celebrities wearing the same dress…
    Kate won for me. I like it on Katie Holmes but between the busy print and the curly hair, its just too much.

  12. bm March 21, 2012 at 20:05 #

    Very impressive dress that made 7 celebs done this.

  13. Amy March 21, 2012 at 22:21 #

    OMG, this look is the proof that Katie Holmes needs to hang out with VB again. Damn she was so bold and chic in those days. I think she’s the winner : amazing print, amazing fit, modern hair.
    I want this Katie back!!

  14. manja March 22, 2012 at 08:28 #

    agree with you FC,best is Katie Holmes by far

  15. EmmaWoodhouse March 23, 2012 at 00:41 #

    Kate Beckinsale for me! I also really liked how the silhouette on Leelee–she looks so chic :)

  16. lola March 23, 2012 at 02:50 #

    This dress is beyond hideous. I’ts not the ugly pepto bismal pink and choice of fabric that’s most shocking, its the fact that this dress has been circulating around hollywood for five years.If I had to choose someone it would be katie holmes- its the easiest on the eye.

  17. Jess2 March 23, 2012 at 03:30 #

    I went with Katie because she looks amazing, I love the different print and her styling, this really was a great time for her style wise. Kate was a very very close second as she also looked gorgeous and I loved that she was wearing peep toes :)
    Soaking up the undeniable brillinace that was and is Alexander McQueen!!

  18. nats April 22, 2012 at 03:31 #

    Kate Beckinsale hands down

Leave a Reply

Latest on Red Carpet fashion Awards