Who Wore Giles Better? Lily Cole or Pixie Geldof

Lily Cole posed on the red carpet at InStyle & HFPA’s annual event during the 2011 Toronto Film Festival last month wearing a Giles Fall 2011 dress.

The model/actress teamed her long-sleeved dress featuring Paul Delaroche’s painting of ‘The Execution of Lady Jane Grey’ with a black waistband and eggplant pumps.

Pixie Geldof wore the same dress when she sat front row at the Giles Spring 2012 presentation in London a few days later.

The social butterfly tied her hair back into a loose bun and accessorized with gold bag and black Miu Miu peep-toes.

I love that Pixie wore her hair off her shoulders to show off the details on her dress, but I think this dress works better on someone statuesque like Lily.

Lily’s eggplant coloured heels also complement the dress better so she wins for me.

Credit: Style.com & Getty

Kate Upton In WilliamVintage - 'The Other Woman' London Premiere

Kate Upton In WilliamVintage – ‘The Other Woman’ London Premiere

Who Wore Prabal Gurung Better? Rose Byrne or Amanda Hearst

Who Wore Prabal Gurung Better? Rose Byrne or Amanda Hearst

8 Responses to Who Wore Giles Better? Lily Cole or Pixie Geldof

  1. robbie October 17, 2011 at 11:52 #

    lilt for me. although i am shocked pixie doesnt look like a corpse for once.

  2. Fashion Foie Gras October 17, 2011 at 11:59 #

    I love how Pixie has grown up over the past couple of weeks in terms of her fashion! It’s incredible! Has she hired a stylist?

    • Fashion Critic October 17, 2011 at 12:10 #

      Not sure.

      Like you said it could just be a case of her growing up

  3. abisi October 17, 2011 at 12:16 #

    Definitely Lily Cole! Loooove

  4. f4fashion October 17, 2011 at 13:33 #

    Eventhough I prefer Pixie’s hairstyle, attitude and accessories, the dress looks tailored to fit Lily’s body so she wins for me.

  5. Jeremy October 17, 2011 at 14:01 #

    Am I the only one who mistaken Pixie for Kate Moss in this picture?
    On a side-note: I voted for Pixie because Lily’s 2-sizes-too-big shoes irked me a lot.

  6. Marybeth October 18, 2011 at 01:56 #

    I’ll vote for Lily because I like the color of the dress with her red hair.
    (Too bad about the boats on her feet.)

Leave a Reply

Latest on Red Carpet fashion Awards