When Saoirse Ronan attended the New York screening of her movie ‘Hanna’ back in April, she wore a Chanel Pre-Fall 2011 dress with Jimmy Choo ‘Zone’ silver strappy sandals.

Her multi-coloured metallic polka-dot halter dress had an exquisite bejeweled neckline and was also accented with an embellished waistband.

Clemence Poesy wore the same dress to the Chanel Spring 2012 presentation during Paris Fashion Week exactly 6 months later.

The French actress swapped the embellished waistband for a velvet one.

Black Miu Miu suede peep-toes and a silver clutch completed her look.

Clemence wins for me.

I much prefer the silhouette of her dress with the velvet waistband and I think the overall fit is better on her.

Credit: Style.com, Gregorio T. Binuya/Everett Collection. & Getty