Carrie Underwood was the first to wear this stunning red Edition by Georges Chakra Fall 2010 gown last year to the 2010 American Country Awards.

The Country music singer wore her asymmetrical red chiffon gown with beaded cummerbund and beaded tulle bodice with Rene Caovilla gold heels, Coomi jewels and a gold Rene Caovilla sequin clutch.

Sarah ‘try way too’ Harding wore the same dress to be 2011 BAFTA Awards last week.

She totally ruins the look for me with the full on red lips, eye make-up, frizzy locks, red platform heels and black clutch.

There is nothing subtle about this look. It’s too ‘in ya face’ for my liking.

Class and sophistication wins over desperate to be noticed, so Carrie wins for me.

Credit: NYMag.com & Getty