Anne Hathaway looked stunning wearing a sapphire Marchesa feathered cocktail dress to the “Valentine’s Day” LA Premiere back in February.

The actress accessorized her dress with Garrard by Georgina Chapman diamond feather earrings and a Roger Viver black jewel encrusted clutch.

Katharine McPhee wore the same dress this month when she performed on ‘The CBS ‘Early Show’ in New York City.

I love how Katharine’s version is less tame than Anne’s dress and I also prefer Katharine’s strappy nude sandals, so she wins for me.

Credit: Startraks Photo/Rex Features & Getty