21.11.10 X Factor

X Factor: Saturday Week 7 – Cheryl Cole In Falguni and Shane Peacock

I want to focus on fashion, but last night on the X Factor Cheryl Cole proved that despite all the designer clothes, the L’Oreal contract and the best efforts of her PR team to make us forget about the Cheryl Tweedy who attacked a toilet attendant, she still has no class.

I lost total and utter respect for her when she used the show to try to publicly humiliate Wagner over some false media story in the Mirror of all papers. Like it’s the holy bible of truth.

She reminded us that the show isn’t about the contestants vying for a £1 million recording contract, but that the show is ALL ABOUT HER.

She needs to count her blessing because she can’t sing and she did get lucky, so she needs to climb down from her high horse and get over herself.

You can read her embarrassing attack on Wagner here.

As for what she wore on Saturday night I think Julien MacDonald summed up my feelings on her style this week when he allegedly said to her, “Who are you trusting and who are you working with? What are you thinking?” To which she allegedly ran off crying.

Truth hurts. Allegedly.

Cheryl’s lost her mojo. She doesn’t care anymore and this “Dancing On Ice” costume proved that.

I can’t wait for the public apology tonight which will be scripted to perfection by her PR team.

Thanks to High Heel Confidential for identifying Cheryl’s dress.

Credit: Ken McKay/TalkbackThames/Rex Features

Irina Shayk In Azzedine Alaia - Extra

Irina Shayk In Azzedine Alaia – Extra

X Factor: Saturday Week 7 – Dannii Minogue In Gucci

X Factor: Saturday Week 7 – Dannii Minogue In Gucci

92 Responses to X Factor: Saturday Week 7 – Cheryl Cole In Falguni and Shane Peacock

  1. mark November 21, 2010 at 12:16 #

    last night was the first time this series i actually liked her whole look.
    i can’t stand her though, total chav and needs to find another synonym for ‘thoroughly’.

  2. jennifer November 21, 2010 at 12:31 #

    I completely agree with you on both counts- she looked awful last night and the fiasco with Wagner only proved that she has no class.

  3. annie November 21, 2010 at 12:39 #

    she has no class and no idea that the world does not revolve around her, i guess the backlash has started, but this reminds me more that i love danni!!!
    i also hate cheryls fat ankles!

  4. mehbuba November 21, 2010 at 12:42 #

    you summed her up perfectly !

  5. Helen November 21, 2010 at 12:43 #

    The Wagner situation was inapropriate but Julien MacDonald is hardly class personified either.
    I agree about the ice – skater reference but I thought she looked good last night and I loved the hair.

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 12:45 #

      I agree Julien isn’t. She clearly was still upset about that and took it out on Wagner.

      • michelle November 21, 2010 at 12:50 #

        clearly, because she made a fool out of herself last night.

      • Helen November 21, 2010 at 13:17 #

        I agree, it wasn’t fair especially since it is more than likely that his words were taken out of context and even if they weren’t ,live on telly after his preformance was not the place to address it.
        She won’t be disciplined either because she is too cosy with Simon.
        Did Julien design that dress?

        • Helen November 21, 2010 at 13:18 #

          Sorry, scratch the designer question, just saw a previous comment about the designer.

  6. anu November 21, 2010 at 13:01 #

    i absolutely have NO words for her!

    moving on.. ‘ ‘“Dancing On Ice” costume ‘ describes her outfit completely! LOLLL this is why i love you FC! xxx

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 13:09 #

      thanks x

  7. mark November 21, 2010 at 13:02 #

    do you know the designer fc?

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 13:10 #

      no I don’t

  8. Karis November 21, 2010 at 13:03 #

    I totally agree Fashion Critic, hear hear!

  9. Marvel November 21, 2010 at 13:07 #

    FC, I must admit Im surprised that you laid into Cheryl like that. I know your a massive fan of hers (or once was), as I am, but I agree with you in her having no class and her being a puppet to her PR team.

    I think she used the platform to make sure Wagner got out instead of her beoved Katie, when in actual fact, I think Wagner may have more votes this weekend

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 13:12 #

      I hate bullies, and she was a total bully last night.

      I see her in a totally different light now. She disgusted me

      • annie November 21, 2010 at 13:22 #

        leopard never changes its spots, i’m glad everyone can see what type of girl she is, no matter what she wears she will always be a bully

      • RG November 21, 2010 at 17:57 #

        Now I remembered when she attacked Victoria Beckham and her royal poshness didn’t even give a damn. Maybe VB thought that she’s nothing but a second rate trying hard copycat. And I really think that she is. The weird part and the thing that I hate the most was when VB achieved something in the US and managed to get some A-list people on her social circle all of a sudden this girl apologized. I didn’t find any sincerity in her apology and I guess this is the reason why.

        • Lily November 21, 2010 at 18:41 #

          OMG really?? i love VB, sometimes jealousy really leads u to a bad place like cheryl has now..

      • gylo November 22, 2010 at 00:56 #

        You aren’t right… do you know why? because WAGNER said those words, they are recorded. Like Cheryl said on XTRA FACTOR tonight, she had factual prove he said those words and his behaviour around her was really strange and only showed he really said those things.

        • Fashion Critic November 22, 2010 at 01:29 #

          Sorry but I’m not going to drag this on anymore. This is the last comment I will make on this post.

          I’m have explained clearly that my problem was her outburst. I don’t care what Wagner said. She was unprofessional.

          I don’t watch the Xtra Factor

        • MartaEC_Spain November 22, 2010 at 01:48 #

          I prefer to post with my real name… why it was unprofessional? to set the record straight is being unprofessional? so being hypocritical is now called being professional? Talking about being bullied, if you’re bullied at school or at your job you can’t have “an ourbust”? I’m not comparing both situations, the thing is that when you adress something publicly then it’s easier than the other person stops doing what he was doing. I agree with you when you say this show is a joke, a complete joke, but it is not new, last year it was a joke too.

  10. anne November 21, 2010 at 13:15 #

    Thank God you’ve come to that conclusion too FC. I didn’t post anything for the last couple of weeks because my dislike for her, Simon and the show was growing with each week, reaching it’s climax last week with Aiden’s elimination, but i knew you still liked her.
    She’s always going on and on about the media fabricating stories about her acts but she takes for granted everything related to her. Like you’ve said, i’ve lost all respect for her and i really hope she won’t be a judge on xf u.s. because we’ll be seeing her play the good girl again before she shows her true colours.

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 13:29 #

      She will not be on the X Factor in the US. If she had even a slightest chance she blew it last night.

      • anne November 21, 2010 at 13:40 #

        I hope so…but with Simon eating out the palm of her hand and the likes of Rihanna and Fergie praising her for her beauty you never know. She’ll probably do another interview with Piers posing as a victim once more to redeem herself for last night.

        • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 13:43 #

          I think it’s between Nicole Scherzinger and Katy Perry.

    • michelle November 21, 2010 at 16:28 #

      @FC, I think nicole will get it

      • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 16:33 #

        Yes she is the stronger contender

  11. Mrs. A November 21, 2010 at 13:15 #

    Nothing wrong with her outfit. She looks great. Could it be that your opinion of her outburst is clouding your judgement? On someone else, you would have praised this outfit.

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 14:28 #

      This is ridiculous.

      I don’t like the dress. I didn’t like it the second she stepped out.

      What does her outburst have to do with my opinion on her dress?

      The two are totally separate. I’ve not like much of what she has worn all season.

      I hate the sheer sleeves, I’ve said that many times on this site and this dress has sheer sleeves.

      A dress like this belongs at an ice-rink.

  12. lilflowa November 21, 2010 at 13:26 #

    I completely agree with everything you said. I’ve never jumped on this Cheryl bandwagon simple because she is constantly shoved in our faces as someone we should simple adore, who’s so precious and meek and uber talented…not.

    The PR team can spin all they want but they can’t control her mouth. Ha. Let’s see hw they bring this 1 back around.

    Danni all the way. I always root for the underdog who is usually underestimated on top of it all.

  13. Dinesh November 21, 2010 at 13:29 #

    I too am surprised you laid into her that much. As much as i adore Cheryl, i do partly agree with you about her comment to Wagner last night. However, i think she was more frustrated than anything else that much better acts like Aiden, John and Treyc were going home over him.

    I don’t think it reflects on her class. She is facing the same frustration that many are that Wagner is still in the competition. Was it right to use that time to criticize him ? No. Does it mean she is classless ? Absolutely not.

    And the attack was seven years ago. I say let sleeping dogs lie.

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 13:33 #

      yes and in seven years she’s still acting like an entitled bully.

  14. Jarrold November 21, 2010 at 13:43 #

    I think you might be blonded by hate because I really like this look, one of the best looks from her, Im in the US so I dont really know her whole story, but I really like this looks one of her best on the X Factor this season.

  15. k.b.s November 21, 2010 at 14:02 #

    No class. No talent. No taste. Just hype and dimples. it’s a long way down when you’ve only got your ego to accompany you.

    • KateS November 22, 2010 at 00:44 #

      lol! I agree 100%

  16. pink November 21, 2010 at 14:12 #

    I was totally astounded by Cheryl’s outburst. I hadn’t read the papers as yet so knew nothing about it. She was totally unprofessional and it was inappropriate. Worse than that she have credence to a press story. I thought Wagner’s reply was excellent and she just ended up looking foolish. I can see why her PR team will not allow her to have a Twitter account.

  17. Caroline November 21, 2010 at 14:25 #

    Woah, some disliking going on in the comment section! I agree that the outfit is not the greatest and the comment towards Wagner was a bit inappropriate, but to praise Dannii is just whack! Remember her comments towards Danyl last season about the gay-rumors? Worse!

    • Rachel November 21, 2010 at 16:03 #

      Those comments were way out of line! Disgusting!

      • Caroline November 21, 2010 at 16:32 #

        Wait what? I am a bit confused now? I didn’t even say anything mean??

        • Rachel November 21, 2010 at 17:43 #

          Sorry! English is not my first language. I meant Danny’s comments about Danyl being gay or not! Those comments were out of line! Not your comments!

    • michelle November 21, 2010 at 16:30 #

      I dannii didn’t mean it in a malicious way and she did apologise after.

  18. Alicat November 21, 2010 at 14:29 #

    Those sheer sleeves are seriously icky. More mini dresses, shiny legs and clunky shoes. It’s her “style” folks.

  19. Coco's Tea Party November 21, 2010 at 14:33 #

    I really don’t like Cheryl Cole, the whole innocent victim act is really annoying, and I think it makes her a really bad role model for girls, so it upsets me she’s always ‘best dressed’ and ‘woman of the year’. I think people are finally getting bored of Cheryl now, about time! Glad you posted this!

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 14:36 #

      You’re welcome.

      I don’t like to go off on a non-fashion related rant, but she totally embarrassed herself.

      • Kate McCarthy November 21, 2010 at 15:44 #

        ok.lets calm down Fashion Critic.Cheryl most likely felt like she was standing up for everyone who has been called a chav or that being from a council house is an insult.it’s not yet the press reports that it is.Also what she said in actual fact was for him to stop focusing on her being lucky and focus on himself because lets face it-he is VERY lucky.its hardly cause to completly dismiss her!seriously,she may have just lost her patience,shes human and that was some furious backpedalling by Wagner,he had to leave the x factor house because he doesnt get on with anyone,hes hardly a saint.

  20. stella November 21, 2010 at 15:07 #

    Well, I think what she did was wrong…but you gotta admit that whatever Wagner might have done was also out of line. It didn’t matter if he really said the stuff or not. In the first place, he shouldn’t have. And I think Cheryl should have taken the high road. But I guess if someone did the same to you, you might wanna shame them to death too. I’m not siding with Cherly nor am I siding with Wagner. I’m just saying coming from where people had spread lies and rumours about me, I think they deserved to be shamed.

    On the sidenote, I think her dress should have no sheer sleeves.

    • Onionviper November 21, 2010 at 20:05 #

      lies? he only said the truth

  21. Victoria November 21, 2010 at 15:33 #

    Hi FC, I’m from Asia and so have do not have much of an idea about Cheryl Cole. I was just curious to know what a council estate girl means?

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 15:44 #

      It’s very long to explain, but it basically means she came from a poor background or a rough part of town.

      In America it would be referred to as the Projects

      • Lee Ann November 21, 2010 at 18:25 #

        Actually in America she would referred to as trailer trash. The projects only applies to certain big cities.

        • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 18:28 #

          Yes. That is more appropriate. Thank you

  22. Vivian November 21, 2010 at 15:34 #

    Caroline, Dannii didn’t out Danyl. She was supporting him which he later said he appreciated and if you look back on the video of it you will see Danyl agreeing with Dannii saying he’s not ashamed.

    I agree with your post about Cheryl. I’ve never rated her style or her supposed looks and she’s just nasty.

    • Caroline November 21, 2010 at 16:34 #

      Glad you cleared that up.
      I didn’t have the whole story. :)

  23. Jones19 November 21, 2010 at 15:45 #

    I’ve always seen Cheryl as a talentless hack, I don’t get why she’s on such a high pedestal in the UK.

  24. Hannah November 21, 2010 at 15:59 #

    She should never have been a judge. She is awful, and I much refered Sharon, even if she and Danii hated eachother, it was better than watching Cheryl adn Simon’s pervy and constant ass-licking of one another (excuse my language, I cannot ifnd a better way to put that).
    She is embarassing, and so is her self-entitledness. She acts so high adn mighty, when yes, inreality she didabuse a toilet attendant, and let’s be honest, without ‘pop stars the rivals’ she probably would have been one too.
    I think it is bizarre for people to say that she got the X factor job because she is the prettiest, almost all of her bandmates are prettier, it is because she was a WAG, and therefore more famous.
    Speakign of Girls Aloud, she cannot sing and she not decide to be a solo singer.
    Her attack on Wagner was beyond embarassing, although he is ridiculous, and he cannot sing that well (esepcially thesongs given to him), he has a lot more class, humility and is much mroe a gentleman (obviously in Cheryl’s case a lady) than Cheryl, and he handled the situation much better.
    Speaking of, how can she claim that what he said was true, when stories abouther acts, published in the same papers are not.
    Sorry about the rant, I just have strong opinions.
    Thankyou for this FC, I was worried you would say that Wagner is the bitch, and not Cheyl, but as always on your site honestly prevails.
    The X factor is a sham, and that clearly manifests itself in her.

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 16:14 #

      No way…I’ve always hated bullies. I would never defend that type of behaviour

  25. Cam November 21, 2010 at 16:16 #

    I’ve always thought she was a ridiculous woman.
    Beauty can make people self centered, narcissistic and seriously self justified!

    Also I so agree with your comment that she’s very lucky!
    Loved this post, well done FC!

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 16:29 #

      thank you Cam. I know it’s off topic – fashion – but I was still fuming from watching the show yesterday.

  26. Lily November 21, 2010 at 16:19 #

    lol.. FC review today is a surprise bcoz even i haven’t really comments too much but I regularly open this website 3/4 times a day this is the first time you seems to hate a person.

    I hv no idea who she is actually, all that i know she’s the ex-wife of ashley cole, n member of girls aloud (which i don’t familiar either). I guess in asia, not so much people know her. I googled n find out she’s being a racist. Not nice, I know how it feels when somebody attack your race.

    well, i don’t really know what to say actually.. oh I agree with the ice skate comment, n.. keep up the good work.. ^^

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 16:30 #

      Thanks. Hate is a strong word. I just don’t agree with her behaviour. There is a time and a place for these types of discussions and it wasn’t on live TV

      • Lily November 21, 2010 at 18:46 #

        totally agree..

  27. Tamia November 21, 2010 at 16:49 #

    I am no big fan of cheryls but that julien mcdonald story is ridiculous!as if he would say that to her-he’s the biggest sycophant going!cheryl is one of few celebs his dresses and scores him massive free press when she wears him on xfactor so why would he want to alienate that?!lol

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 16:52 #

      Because she’s no longer wearing his dresses. I think that was the reason for the outburst.

      • Tamia November 21, 2010 at 17:08 #

        ah ok babe,i cant blame her to be honest-Julian is a has-been,she looked incredibly tacky in that gaudy dress of his on the 2008 final. x

  28. Jesse November 21, 2010 at 16:53 #

    Most people appear to be sticking up for Cheryl though, in the papers and such, not on this board. I don’t think they were watching properly.

    On another note, agree with the skater comments. I am in love with Dannii’s jewellery choices this season, fantastic. if I could afford Anoushka I would be buying it by the ship load!

  29. Payal November 21, 2010 at 17:02 #

    Hey FC,
    Cheryl is in a Fall 2010 Falguni and Shane Peacock. http://bit.ly/abwU6c

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 17:18 #

      Thanks Payal x

  30. Vidhya November 21, 2010 at 17:16 #

    This dress is a beautiful Falguni and Shane peacock dress which has been watered down and badly presented by Cheryl on a controversial night.. i feel sad for the indian designers…

  31. Badaboum November 21, 2010 at 17:33 #

    I do not agree 100% with your original comments on Cheryl, but I really respect the fact that you express yourself so freely. Whether it is about Cheryl or an other celeb, I really appreciate your honesty: this is why I (and many other) love you blog.
    I am glad you didn’t “censor” Alice’s comments, I think your response is very classy.

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 17:39 #

      Thank you x

  32. suzy November 21, 2010 at 17:42 #

    Cheryl has shown us that she has not really changed and is the same rude girl from Girls Aloud who used to attack other female celebrities verbally all the time. Ever since the whole Ashley Cole cheating thing her team have been trying to turn her into this nice peoples princess and many people buy the act because she is really attractive and they felt sorry for her. But everything about her is manipulated her “Classy” style and her saintly act . It seems now she has become the most famous woman in the UK she does not care about maintaining her false image and is slipping back (at least in public) to her rude, aggressive and tacky ways. She is paid millions to judge people on their performance and it was classless to attack Wagner, when she should be talking about his performance and that was 100% unprofessional.

    BACK TO HER LOOK
    With her red hair she has to be careful because it is very easy to look tacky if she does not think about how the whole look comes together.

  33. Lucy November 21, 2010 at 18:16 #

    I totally agree, 100%. If she didn’t still act like a chav from a acouncil estate then people would not feel the need to bring it up so much. She thinks she is bigger than the show itself and can do no wrong, including her fashion choices. She embarassed herself more than Wagner in this cheap and nasty confrontation

  34. Lily November 21, 2010 at 18:18 #

    I completely understand where you are coming from. I also grew up in a council estate but despite a serious lack of cash I was raised with class. Last night’s behaviour proves that no amount of sparkle and PR spin can make Cheryl a dignified person. I commend you and all the others from council estates for soaring high, working hard and not forgetting our roots.

  35. anne November 21, 2010 at 18:27 #

    I really don’t understand fandom taken to new levels…regular people sticking up for their favourite celebrity as if they know who they are for real even when the facts are there in your face. And the thing i’ve always liked about you FC is that not matter how much you like a celeb( see VB or even Cheryl) you’ll be the first to criticize her, which i think it’s the right thing to do. So people trying to make something else of this story and tell us that what we saw it’s not true, need to stop giving Cheryl so many free passes. End of rant and back to fashion :D.

    • Fashion Critic November 21, 2010 at 18:29 #

      thanks Anne.

  36. mochababe73 November 21, 2010 at 19:09 #

    I actually love the dress. She looks great in it. I haven’t seen her look this good in quite some time.
    I don’t know anything about the X-factor, so I can’t comment on the show. We dont’ get it in America.

  37. Onionviper November 21, 2010 at 19:59 #

    oh god, her look is horrible, her hair looks bicolor, I can’t believe she has hairdressers to do that mess.
    I don’t agree with the dancing on ice reference, because I am a great fan of figure skating and those ice dancers dress better than her.

    Also, I love your blog. I’ve been lurking for some time :)

  38. Fola November 21, 2010 at 22:24 #

    I completely agree with you FC. Me and my mum were in shock at what she did to Wagner, he didn’t deserve that on national TV, especially as it was written in a tabloid newspaper. TBH I was surprised she thought that was the right time and place to address the situation.

    As for this outfit…I have no words

  39. 2c November 22, 2010 at 00:40 #

    FC, you just don’t understand how much I agree with you…me and my sister were in complete shock she really showed her true colours in my opinion

  40. MartaEC November 22, 2010 at 01:36 #

    I love how judgemental are some of the comments on here. Do you know what happened behind the scenes? I agree that maybe Cheryl could have handed very different the situation (as Simon a couple of weeks before saying the same as Cheryl sis yesterday)

    Today Cheryl was asked about it on Xtra Factor, a woman said: “You’ve had 24 hours to think about what you said to Wagner last night, do you regret what you said to him?”

    Cheryl answered: “If someone wants to say something publicly then he should be able to adress it publicy which was what I did”

    The other women says: “and do you not think it would have been more professional to do it backstage?”

    Cheryl: “No, no”

    Konnie asks her about all the things the tabloids prints every week and then Cheryl says:

    “The thing is that when you are backstage you get a sense of what is going on”

    Konnie: “yeah, got you”

    Then the woman sarcastically says: “But Cheryl, I’m sure you’ve been misquoted on the press as well before”

    Cheryl: “Yes I have, 100% I have, but I wouldn’t have adressed it if I didn’t know it was factual”

    —-

    There you go, I’m sure she’s heard the illegal interview to Wagner because it is not the first time a bad comment about her has been published on the papers (since the backlash started it’s a daily routine) but she never said something about it, why? because she knew they weren’t true and were made up by the press. Yes, she could have adressed it in private, but she has a point.

  41. gabs November 22, 2010 at 02:02 #

    That dress just screams figure skater! ew. Even her shoes are the color of her skin like in figure skating. Hate the look She could look much prettier and younger in something colorful. These neutral colors she keeps wearing age her.

    I dont understand the comparisons to VB. Im American so I dont know much about this story but if it was about a judge disrespecting a contestant, thats pretty unproffesional so…I guess I agree with you

  42. Scarlett November 22, 2010 at 02:45 #

    This whole thing about Cheryl Cole being the nation’s sweetheart, the poor girl who got cheated on by her unfaithful husband basically doesn’t allow her to make any faults. We’ve sort of built her up and put her on a pedestal and with that in mind, its easier to knock her down. Was she wrong and unprofessional in saying that? Absolutely. I mean it was very unprofessional but she is human and we’ve got to cut her some slack. The fact that Wagner is still on the show is pretty pathetic and she’s frustrated that better acts have come and gone. She didn’t handle it very well but I saw the clips and I didn’t think that she was that disrespectful. And with people constantly calling her a chav, it’s no wonder she wants to defend her roots and her upbringing. But honestly, I think she could have handled it better. It was unfair right after Wagner’s performance. But I think we’re all going a little too far, yes she shouldn’t have done that, but it doesn’t change the fact that she is a nice person who makes mistakes, as all of us do. I like the fact that even though people are against her, she stands up for herself and is willing to take the slack. Not the best situation for sure but hey, it happens. I just wish she would have handled it better, saying it backstage with him for starters and not on national TV.
    I think we’re all getting a bit bored of Cheryl now, because she’s one of the most beautiful women on our TV today and the whole “poor girl that became a princess” situation is becoming a bit boring. She’s flawed as we all are and we should cut her a bit of slack. Saying that, I do think she should apologize to him.

    As for her fashion, I completely agree. She is of course stunningly gorgeous but her fashion has been lackluster, I think I only liked one or two of her outfits this season. I don’t think she tries as hard as she used to. Dannii, on the other hand, has been effortlessly glamorous.

    I still love Cheryl but she’s losing a bit of her star quality that made her so likeable.

  43. karen November 22, 2010 at 08:06 #

    I’m from the US so I don’t know what all the fuss is about regarding Cheryl and the contestant. All I know is that Cheryl is a gorgeous young girl and young people say inappropriate things at times. I like Cheryl, although I have to say this dress is not flattering on her and the hair looks so fake and cheap.

  44. seggie November 22, 2010 at 09:40 #

    OMG!!! I don’t have the internet at home and I was dying to read your thoughts about Cheryl Cole and Good Lord I’m loving this post!!! FC you totally made my day!!
    I used to be a big fan of Cheryl and I gone off her in the last year because I can totally see she never changed, she’s a fame whore and a narcissic opportunist. Her fashion sense is revolting as much as she is.
    She definitely embarrassed and exposed herself and I loved it!
    She should be so lucky as Kylie once said :-)

  45. Ayesha November 22, 2010 at 10:08 #

    she’s insane and quite dumb actually.i never liked her much and after this no way!

  46. Rachel November 22, 2010 at 11:30 #

    She is currently refusing to apologise, so this will drag on. Most likely untill Wagner is voted off. I think we mush be objective about the dress: the embroidery is artfully done and looked well under studio lights.We shouldn’t punish Fulgani and Shane Peacock. This site is about fashion, I don’t think her hair should be so much of an issue. Whoa, though, what right did Julian MacDonald have to attack her(if that story was true, seems out of character for him)?Not his business in the least.

    • Rachel November 22, 2010 at 11:34 #

      Apologies, Falguni and Shane Peacock

  47. dan November 23, 2010 at 15:50 #

    i think cheryl was right to say whatever she thinks apparently its a free country where people can voice their own oppinions as for wagner hes a total looser. and danni was soo annoying saturday she was moaning about everyone but personally xfactor is dry this year.

  48. MissMarlboroLites November 24, 2010 at 14:01 #

    I had to explain this same situation to my boyfriend. Each week my fav part of the show is when the judges come out and each week Cheryl is never a clear winner. Dannii is simply coming into her own, dressing fantastically to suit her. Seeing the dress again, you can appreciate the work but it simply did not suit Cherly; in my opinion it made her look hefty, which she is certainly not. I can only assume that there is a stylist somewhere suggesting she dress fierce and she is agreeing.

    Also FC, I am keen to know your thoughts about Sunday’s outfits. I can’t see anything more has been posted since Saturday’s and I hope that this has noting to do with the comments above? And of course please do point out if you have posted and I am missing it?!

    • Fashion Critic November 24, 2010 at 14:29 #

      I didn’t feature it and yes it does have to do with the comments above.

      With regards to their looks I didn’t like either. Dannii to flamenco and Cheryl same old same old boring

  49. MissMarlboroLites November 25, 2010 at 12:41 #

    Oh, no! I really look forward to reading your thoughts on Monday morning, it’s one of the things I most look foward to! Having said that, I do understand why you may not want to comment on Sunday’s outfits given some of the comments above but I would be sad to think that some comments on this thread would have this effect.
    Please say that you will continue with outfits in future weeks?!
    And btw, I did not like Dannii’s flamenco dress, not very flattering but I thought Cheryl had improved, although she’s nowhere near where she used to be.

Leave a Reply

Latest on Red Carpet fashion Awards