It’s rare to see celebs wearing the same vintage piece, but we all know that Rachel Zoe has a huge vintage Halston collection.

At the 2010 Vanity Fair Oscar Party back in March, Marisa Tomei wore her deep blue bugle beaded vintage Halston dress from Decades with a black satin obi sash tied to the waist.

Her look was paired with Sergio Rossi heels and H Stern jewels.

Rachel Zoe wore her dress to the CFDA Fashion Awards with the Casadei 3504 triple platform pumps she made famous with her A list clients.

Although I wish Marisa wore her dress without such a wide belt, I do love the deeper plunge.

I don’t think I can ever truly love or even like a look with those Casadei heels, so Marisa wins for me.

Credit: Fame Pictures & Getty