We’re used to seeing stars don the same dresses within weeks or months months of each other, but rarely do we see stars wearing looks six years apart.

That was the case with Claire Danes and Jamie Winstone who both wore this Alexander McQueen Fall 2004 gown.

Claire Danes wore the nude gown with the contrasting criss-cross stripes to the Costume Institute Gala back in April 2004.

The blonde actress teamed her gown with a softly curled updo, delicate drop earrings, fresh-faced make-up and a simple gold clutch.

Jamie wore the dress to the 2010 BAFTAs.

She sported a Marilyn Monroe ‘do and a ruby red pout.

I love that Jamie had fun with this look.

Her ‘do and red lips gave her look character and personality so she wins for me.

Credit: Style.com, Rex & Getty