Eva Green first wore this Christian Dior Fall 2009 fuchsia embroidered gown to the amfAR Cinema Against Aids Benefit during Cannes Film Festival in May of last year.

I usually heart Eva, but here not so much.

Her hair and make up kinda makes her look a little crazy, the eyes especially are WAY too heavy for her.

And I’m not sure that this shade is such a good match with her pale skin.

Carina Lau then wore this dress to the Huabiao Film Awards” in August 2009.

On Carina, I love it.

The gown looks so beautiful against her skin tone and her subtle hair and make up allows the beautiful embellishments to speak for themselves.

I also prefer this dress worn without the sleeves, as Carina has done.

For me Carina is the clear winner.

What do you think?

Credit: Style.com, Getty & Wireimage