Gwyneth Paltrow wore this Preen Fall 2009 dress to the “Champions Of Hope Benefit” in New York in July.

I always love it when Gwyneth wears edgier pieces but I know some of you won’t agree!

I love the LA tan against this futuristic dress. I love the hair and the minimal make-up. And then I saw the boots *sigh*.

Fergie wore this dress at the beginning of December to a press conference with her band the Black Eye Peas in Mexico.

Again I’m not a fan of the shoes. They seem way too dainty for the dress.

It’s a close call and I think that both could have styled the dress the better but on the this occasion I’m going to go for Gwyneth.

A controversial decision I think? Who’s look do you prefer?

This dress is available to buy from Net-A-Porter.com.

Credit: Style.com & Wireimage