Jennifer Morrison wore this very sultry Black Halo pencil dress when she arrives at the Padres Contra El Cancer’s 8th Annual “El Sueno De Esperanza” in California.

The two-toned jacket dress features a flattering sheath silhouette with cap sleeves and a slim textured belt cinching in the waist.

She paired her look with black peep-toes and a sparkling black clutch.

Vanessa Minnillo wore the same dress to the “Step Up Women’s Network’s 2009 Inspiration Awards Luncheon” in Beverly Hills.

She also carried a embellished black bag and wore Christian Louboutin’s making this almost impossible to pick a winner.

In the end I opted for Jennifer because I preferred her shoes to Vanessa.