Back in April 2008 a less edgy Leighton Meester wore an olive and nude Pencey Cummerbund Dress to the premiere of “Killer Movie” at The 2008 Tribeca Film Festival.

It was very early in her red carpet days and she was still very much trying to find her style, as her dress was paired with white pumps.

Amanda Bynes aka ‘The Queen of LBD’s” wore the same dress in black when she walked the red carpet at the “Cosmopolitan’s Fun Fearless Female Dinner” in LA.

LBD – check
Black pumps – check
Black clutch – check

The only surprising thing here is that she’s not wearing Herve Leger.

Leighton wins of course, no question.

You can buy the black version fromn for $333.

Credit: Wireimage