Who Wore Giles Better? Victoria Beckham or Sara Paxton

Victoria Beckham put her best Gucci thigh-high boot forward at Bergdorf Goodman’s celebration of Fashion’s Night Out earlier this month.

The fashion designer wore a reptile print Giles Fall 2009 dress, a black head band and smoky eyes.

Some of you have said that when Sara Paxton wore the same dress to “The Beautiful Life” party, she didn’t know Victoria Beckham had worn the same dress 2 days earlier.

I would say that was impossible. Victoria’s picture was in every paper, website and blog the following day. There is no way Sara and her stylist didn’t know VB wore it.

Sara looks great in the dress, but nothing in the world will make me like those Alejandro Ingelmo woven slingbacks she’s wearing, they don’t seem to work with anything so Victoria wins this for me.

Credit: & Wireimage

Roberto Cavalli Spring 2010

Roberto Cavalli Spring 2010

Sonia Rykiel For H&M

Sonia Rykiel For H&M

  • Ben

    maybe her stylist just sucks

  • kco8489

    I’m sorry but VB looks overly tan and her make up looks atrocious. In contrast, Sara looks very fresh faced and youthful.

  • Parvati

    I voted for Sara Paxton. I hate these shoes, too, but everything else is better on her than on Victoria Beckham. I think Victoria’s boots were a bad choice with this dress and her make-up is horrible, so Sara wins this for me.

  • Catherine

    although i hate Sara’s shoes, i think everything else works for her.
    while i don’t like Victoria’s hair or choice of footwear…

  • Monkey

    VB lost my vote cause of those awful boots and her terrible make up.

  • JacobGH

    honestly not crazy about this dress at all but VB looks a total mess. her makeup particularly is atrocious. sara wins on default. shame about her show being canceled after only two eps. i guess we won’t be seeing her on the red carpet all that much


  • sydneycheapchic

    Sara Paxton because I would vote for anything but the tandoori lollipop head look.. I know it’s about the fashion.. but shouldn’t it look appealing?? sorry to all the fanatics but nothing about VB here looks appealing.

  • Paulie

    I don’t like the shoes either but I’m going with Sara just because she looks healthy.

Latest on Red Carpet fashion Awards