
Mischa Barton had a blast during New York Fashion Week. She was front row a many shows, and she also enjoyed hanging out at some of the hippest parties.
One of those parties was the Marc Jacobs after-show-party held at Hiro in New York.
To that party she wore a black embellished Marc Jacobs Fall 2009 mini dress with lace sleeves and a studded wrap-around belt, plus tights and black flats.
Elettra Wiedemann wore the same dress a few day later when she arrived at “The Burning Plain” premiere at Landmark’s Sunshine Cinema in New York.
She wore a pair of sexy strappy sandals, which I preferred to Mischa’s flats.
As much as I want to give this to Elettra, I really don’t like the way the bottom half of the dress hangs down exposing the lace underlay, which as a result gives the look a maternity feel.
So once again I’m giving a win to Mischa by default.
Selma Blair wore a similar one-sleeved version of this dress to the Costume Institute Gala.

MORE FROM RED CARPET FASHION AWARDS:
Posted by Catherine Kallon on September 24th, 2009 In: Elettra Wiedemann, Marc Jacobs, Mischa Barton, Who Wore It Better?









Beyonce Knowles’ Kurt Geiger ‘Dash’ Rucksack And Karen Walker ‘Blue Moon’ Sunglasses
Lea Michele’s Valentino Lace Dress
Best Dressed Of The Week – Jing Tian In Georges Hobeika Couture & Zac...
Rosie Huntington-Whiteley’s The Row ‘Corby’ Sweater
Rosie Huntington-Whiteley In Emilio Pucci – ‘Hummingbird’ London Premiere
Zhang Yuqi In Elie Saab – Longines Charity Dinner

















They both lose.
My eyes, they burn, they BURN!
Gosh, that’s hideous!
i would name this “Who wore MJ worse”, what a mess
right lol
I was coming to the comments to say the same thing!
I think they both look dreadful.
you’re so right
MTE.
Selma Blair wore a modification of this dress too.
For real, two tragic people screw up an awesome dress. Selma Blair wore a one sleeve version to the MET and rocked it out!
I don’t think it looks that bad on Misha! The tights are working for me and her hair and makeup are good.
SELMA wins it for me. She looked fabulous in the dress as well as the dress looking fabulous on her!
They both look horrendous! Eek.
I see we can all agree on something.
Uhm where is the button to vote for Selma?