As many of you correctly pointed out Carrie Underwood was the first to wear this gorgeous black sequined Pamella Roland Spring 2009 mini dress with silver sequined circles and bell sleeves when she attended the Clive Davis Pre-Grammy Party.

Silver accessories including earrings, a silver clutch and strappy sandals complemented her dress.

Whitney Port wore the same dress recently to the “I Love Gen Art” 15th Anniversary Benefit in New York.

Whitney wore less bling, just a simple ruby ring.

As much as I dislike Carrie’s hair, I hate Whitney’s choice of pumps with this dress so Carrie wins for me.

Credit: Wireimage & NYmag