Jessica Alba first wore this black keyhole dress to her Rise of the Silver Surfer Fantastic Four premiere in Berlin last year. She wore her dress with a pair of black patent platform shoes.

Tracey Edmonds wore the same dress to the First Annual Essence Black Women in Hollywood Luncheon yesterday, a whole 7 months after Jessica.

She wore her dress with a pair of black bowed shoes.

Both women did not over accessorize and both look amazing in this dress, so I have to go with who’s shoes I prefer.

Jessica wins for me.